GMC and Infiniti Drivers Are Some of the Worst Drivers on the Road

By Lesley Green
Tire markes on a road suggesting that someone is a bad driver.
  • Regardless of the type of vehicle a person drives, approximately 13.8% of drivers have been in a collision, and 13.5% have had a ticket.
  • Lincoln drivers are the most accident-prone of the lot, with 17.9% having been in a collision.
  • GMC drivers take the top spot for being the most likely to have a ticket at 19.5%.

Does what you drive affect how you drive? It appears so.

Drivers beware of those behind the wheel of a GMC or an Infiniti. Drivers of these brands of vehicles are more likely to have a less than stellar driving record. At least that's according to the numbers gathered through InsuranceHotline.com.

Which car's owners make the worst and best drivers?

That's the question we set out to answer when we looked at which of the most popular car brands attracted the best and worst drivers.

It turns out GMC drivers take the title for being the worst of the lot, with 16.8% admitting to having an at-fault accident on their record and 19.5% admitting to having a ticket. Not far behind are drivers of the Infiniti brand of vehicle; 16.1% have been in a collision, and 16.4% have a traffic ticket.

In contrast, the best drive a Honda or a MINI. Of Honda drivers, for example, 12.1% have been in a collision, and 11.4% have a ticket on their records. Even better behind the wheel are MINI drivers; only 11.5% of MINI drivers have been in an accident, and 11.0% have a ticket.

For comparison, the average across the most popular brands is 13.8% for at-fault collisions and 13.5% for tickets.

Quick Car Insurance Quote

Find your best car insurance rate by comparing car insurance quotes from 30+ providers in a single search. Start saving today!

The 5 worst drivers

Lincoln drivers are the accident-prone of the group, with 17.9% having been in a collision, while GMC drivers take the top spot for being the most likely to have a ticket at 19.5%.

Meanwhile, both GMC and Infiniti drivers are repeat offenders – they crack the top five in both lists -- which is why they’re labelled as being some of the worst drivers on the road.

Accident Prone (Collision on record: Average is 13.8%) Ticket Takers (Ticket on record: Average is 13.5%)
Lincoln 17.9% GMC 19.5%
GMC 16.8% Chrysler 17.6%
Cadillac 16.5% Dodge 17.5%
Infiniti 16.1% Jeep 17.0%
Ford 15.9% Infiniti 16.4%

The 5 best drivers

At 9.6%, drivers of the eco-friendly Tesla are the least likely to have a collision on their driving record, making them the smoothest (and coolest) operators on the road. Toyota drivers are the most likely to mind the rules of the road and are the least likely to have a ticket.

Meanwhile, both MINI and Honda drivers crack the top five in both lists -- which is why they’re labelled as being some of the best drivers on the road.

Smooth Operators (Collision on record: Average is 13.8%) Rules of the Road (Ticket on record: Average is 13.5%)
Tesla 9.6% Toyota 9.9%
MINI 11.5% Suzuki 10.5%
Honda 12.1% MINI 11.0%
Porsche 12.2% Honda 11.4%
Audi 12.5% Nissan 11.7%

Steer clear of high car insurance premiums.

Your driving record matters, and it is in your hands to control.

Your driving record is one of the most influential factors in determining your car insurance rate. Sure, there are others like where you live, your insurance history, and the type of car you drive, but your driving record and history indicate how you are when behind the wheel.

Every at-fault (or partially at-fault) accident or traffic ticket conviction will likely increase the cost of your premium. So, no matter what you drive, drive carefully and mind the rules of the road to keep your car insurance premiums low.

About the numbers

The numbers are based on the self-disclosed driving records of drivers in Ontario and in Alberta who got car insurance quotes at InsuranceHotline.com and who then took the next step to secure the great rate they received online from us.

These people weren’t just kicking the tires of our comparison tool; these are drivers whose intent was to buy a policy based on the information they provided. The data spanned three years, from 2018 through to May 2021.