Cheap Hamilton Car Insurance Quotes

Jump straight to...

• How does Hamilton auto insurance work?
• Mandatory & optional coverages in Hamilton
• How much does car insurance in Hamilton cost?
• Hamilton car insurance rates by postal code
• Factors that influence your Hamilton auto insurance premium
• Tips to get cheap car insurance quotes in Hamilton
• Hamilton auto insurance frequently asked questions

How does Hamilton auto insurance work?

Auto insurance for Hamilton drivers is a mandatory requirement just like anywhere in Ontario. Hamilton auto insurance is regulated by the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRAO). The Financial Services Regulatory Authority monitors agents and businesses in Hamilton that sell automobile insurance to make sure they follow all legislative guidelines and rules. FSRA allows them to cover their operating cost, future claims from consumers and their own profit in the proposed rates, while making sure that the rates are reasonable for consumers.

Enforcing the law of the road

Vehicle owners, lessees, and drivers who do not carry valid auto insurance can be subject to a hefty fine ranging from $5,000 to $50,000 on the first instance. If you are found driving without valid auto insurance, you can have your driver's licence suspended and your vehicle seized on the second or subsequent instance. The Compulsory Automobile Insurance Act requires every owner or lessee of a motor vehicle to insure that vehicle if it is being operated on the road. The Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO), along with the Ministry of Transportation and local police services, enforce that Act by prosecuting offences in court and by imposing fines on those violating the rules.

No-fault car insurance

In Ontario, drivers involved in an accident can each file claims to their respective auto insurance providers for getting coverage for the damage caused to their vehicle due to the collision or to cover cost of injury if any. This is called first-party claim or more commonly known as "no-fault" insurance. Unlike its name, no-fault insurance does not mean that the driver is not at fault. It only means that insurance companies will take their time to assess the damage and conclude who the at-fault driver is. Sometimes, only one driver is at-fault for an accident and the other is deemed to be not-at-fault. Other times, both drivers can be found to be at-fault to varying degrees.

Fault determination

If your insurance company determines you're at-fault partially or entirely, and you have collision coverage, you'll need to pay the deductible to repair the damage to your car before your insurance provider pays. An at-fault collision will remain on your driving record for up to six years, and it will affect your premium. That means your existing insurance provider may raise your premium at renewal unless you have an accident-forgiveness endorsement on your policy. If you do, your premium won’t go up, but if you have another collision, there will be no accident forgiveness for a second incident.

Since a fault determination goes on your driving record, other insurers will be aware of it, and they too may quote you a higher premium if you change companies. However, some insurers may be more forgiving than others, so it’s worthwhile to shop around for policies and premiums to find the lowest rate.

Mandatory & optional coverages in Hamilton

How much does car insurance in Hamilton cost?

Auto insurance premium varies from driver to driver, depending upon various factors like driving pattern and history, neighbourhood, the type of car, crime rate, among others. The city of Hamilton is densely populated and without a doubt it has a significantly big driving population. However, compared with other big cities of Ontario, the average auto insurance premium a Hamilton driver pays is far less than a driver from Vaughan, Ajax, Toronto, Mississauga or Brampton. On an average, a Hamilton driver pays $1,564 annually for car insurance.

Hamilton ranks 30 among the highest premium paying cities in Ontario, with Vaughan drivers paying the highest auto premium at $2,179 annually in 2021. Drivers from other Ontario cities like Ajax, Richmond Hill, Brampton, Mississauga, Pickering, Toronto, contribute to the list of highest auto premiums paid annually in the province. Some reasons why Hamilton auto insurance is cheaper than other Ontario cities, could be less crime rate, car thefts, car accidents and better driving patterns.

Hamilton car insurance rates by postal code

Some Hamilton neighbourhoods have lower average automobile premiums than the others in Hamilton. For instance, a driver living in Creekside Drive (Dundas) pays $1,368 on an average each year. This is significantly lower than a driver living at Cannon Street East or Cumberland Avenue in Hamilton who ends up paying $1,932 every year due to different driving patterns in the neighbourhood.

Source: Insuramap

Factors that influence your Hamilton auto insurance premium

Age, gender and marital status

A driver’s age has a big impact on the premium he or she pays to the auto insurance provider. Drivers in the age group of 16-21, especially males, pay the highest auto insurance premium due to driving patterns. Auto insurance premiums decrease in the mid-twenties and the price gap between men and women drivers fades out by age 30. Rates are the lowest for drivers in their 50s and 60s. In Ontario, while nonbinary drivers are offered female rates, married drivers are perceived as being at lower risk to insure.

Vehicle type

Base model cars tend to fetch lower insurance premiums than ones with luxury trim. This is because basic cars parts are cheaper to repair and replace in case of damage due to collision. When shopping for a new car, remember to factor in insurance costs when deciding between make and models.

Neighbourhood

Your postal code is a significant factor in determining your insurance premium. Insurance companies group drivers by geographic location and examine claims activity within those boundaries. A reckless driver in your neighbourhood could affect your rate. More claims make the rates increase, while fewer claims could help decrease your premium over time.

Driving history

Any convictions under Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act will affect your premiums. Over speeding, driving under the influence of alcohol, and driving without a driver’s license can all lead to conviction and further increase in your auto insurance premium. In Ontario, convictions stay on your insurance record for six years, so protect your driving record.

Your insurance history

If you have many claims on your insurance history, you are likely to be paying a higher premium than others. Traffic convictions have a large impact on your insurance history. Also, failure to pay your auto insurance premiums on time can damage your credibility with your insurer and lead to a massive increase in your premium. It can also result in the cancellation of your policy, which will make finding cheap insurance with another provider nearly impossible.

Another thing that can trigger cancellation driving for a rideshare app without informing your insurer. All rideshare apps offer commercial insurance to drivers, but you're still obligated to let the provider of your personal policy know about your intention to start a new side hustle.

Optional coverages in your policy

Besides the mandatory auto insurance coverage — liability, accident, uninsured driver, and property damage — any additional coverage you choose to enhance your policy will raise your premium.

Your policy's deductibles

A deductible is an amount you agree to pay before your insurance company kicks in with the benefit detailed in your policy. Insurers will lower your premium if you increase a deductible since you’re demonstrating that you're willing to shoulder a greater portion of the cost. If you’re bundling with other insurance products, such as home insurance Insurance companies will reward you for giving them more business by bundling your home and auto policies.

The company’s own insurance claims history

Insurance companies have to ensure they have enough in their coffers to meet their obligations to their policyholders in the present and in the future. That’s why insurance companies are one of the most fiscally conservative entities in the financial marketplace. If insurers observe that they’re paying out more claims than what they’re taking in from payments (tracked using a metric known as the ‘combined ratio’), they will need to increase premiums for their customers.

*Based on the difference between the average lowest auto insurance premium and overall average auto insurance premium from our site in 2019.